National Capital FreeNet / Libertel de la capitale nationale

Windows 10

A Windows 10 store display

This article is designed to collect together identified issues with Microsoft's Windows 10 from experts and the tech media, so that NCF members can make informed decisions as to whether they wish to use this operating system, or install an alternative one on their computer hardware instead.

All new versions of Windows meet some user resistance, although some have genuine concerns that users need to know about before they choose to install it or use it. Vista and Windows 8 did not win widespread support from Windows fans, but all indications are that Windows 10 has some much more serious issues for users to consider prior to installing it than any previous Windows version.

By the end of 2015 issues with Windows 10 encountered by NCF members were causing increased staff and volunteer workload trying to solve them. It is hoped this article will reduce those problems and allow NCF staff and volunteers to concentrate on getting members on-line rather than dealing with the problems generated by members' choice of operating systems.

Contents

Background

Windows 10 is the follow-on operating system to Windows 8 that was released to the public on 29 July 2015.

There was no Windows 9, as CBC explains, "The Redmond, Wash.-based software giant earned scathing reviews for its previous OS, the buggy and awkward Windows 8 (yes, they're skipping version 9)."

Identified Issues

Privacy and Security

In November 2015 Microsoft Corporate Vice President Joe Belfiore confirmed that Windows 10 collects a large amount of data on its users and that most of these features cannot be turned off. Gordon Kelly of Forbes said, "so how concerned should users be about Windows 10’s default data collection policies? I would say very. By default Windows 10 Home is allowed to control your bandwidth usage, install any software it wants whenever it wants (without providing detailed information on what these updates do), display ads in the Start Menu (currently it has been limited to app advertisements), send your hardware details and any changes you make to Microsoft and even log your browser history and keystrokes which the Windows End User Licence Agreement (EULA) states you allow Microsoft to use for analysis."

Keystroke loggers are a common feature in viruses and other malware, but Microsoft includes one in Windows 10. This means that Microsoft has every bit of data you type in your computer, including your credit card numbers, all your sign-ins and passwords, your bank accounts, your love letters, email, everything. Because of its policy of cooperating fully with the US National Security Agency (NSA) this means the US government likely has all your data as well. The keystroke logger cannot be turned off. In the EULA the user agrees that Microsoft can share this information with third parties like advertisers and law enforcement.

During the installation process the user agrees to have their contacts, calender events, speech and handwriting patterns and typing history all recorded by Microsoft, along with your web browsing history, too.

By default when it was first released Windows 10 automatically connected you with any wifi network that it could detect and automatically shared the passwords with your Facebook friends, Skype contacts and Outlook.com contacts, although this could be selected off. This Wifi Sense features also shared your location. In May 2016 this privacy issue was fixed as the feature was "discontinued".

By default Windows 10 secures your hard drive data with a disk encryption key, but as noted Microsoft has the encryption key as it is transmitted to them. Micah Lee wrote "As soon as your recovery key leaves your computer, you have no way of knowing its fate. A hacker could have already hacked your Microsoft account and can make a copy of your recovery key before you have time to delete it. Or Microsoft itself could get hacked, or could have hired a rogue employee with access to user data. Or a law enforcement or spy agency could send Microsoft a request for all data in your account, which would legally compel it to hand over your recovery key, which it could do even if the first thing you do after setting up your computer is delete it."

Windows 10 generates a unique advertising ID for each user on each computer. The ID is used by developers and advertising networks to create and maintain a profile about each user. You can turn this off, but you need to know where to look to do that in the settings.

Although it can be turned off the Cortana voice activated assistant sends everything you say, that is picked up by the computer's microphone, to Microsoft for analysis. Mic Wright of The Next Web says: "because Cortana analyzes speech data, Microsoft collects “your voice input, as well as your name and nickname, your recent calendar events and the names of people in your appointments, and information about your contacts including names and nicknames."

Mic Wright of The Next Web says: "This is the part you should be most concerned about: Microsoft’s new privacy policy is very loose when it comes to when it will or won’t access and disclose your personal data:

We will access, disclose and preserve personal data, including your content (such as the content of your emails, other private communications or files in private folders), when we have a good faith belief that doing so is necessary to protect our customers or enforce the terms governing the use of the services.

I’m not suggesting Microsoft and its lawyers are alone in making provision for such sweeping power over your data, but we should all be very careful about relying on the “good faith” of corporations. I’m not even sure such a thing exists."

C. Mitchell Shaw of The New American says "When Microsoft announced the "free" upgrade, many were left wondering why the Redmond giant would give away licenses to use the new operating system. Now it appears that the reason is simple: greater data-mining opportunities. Windows operating systems have long included security weaknesses that leave users vulnerable to spying and data-mining from others. What is different with the newest iteration of Windows is that Microsoft is directly involved in that spying and data-mining and has built the entire operating system in such a way as to allow it."

Dan Gillmor of Medium.com said "Microsoft’s Windows 10 ... looks more and more like spyware masquerading as an operating system (a characterization that may be unfair, but not by much). Yes, the upgrade from widely installed earlier versions is "free" (as in beer), but it takes some amazing liberties with users’ data and control, according to people who’ve analyzed its inner workings."

An update to Windows 10 in November 2015 returned user's privacy settings to the default without their knowledge. Darren Allan of TechRadar reported "The bug apparently caused Windows 10 to reset four settings to default values. These were privacy settings, which explains why Microsoft was so sensitive about the affair, and they included options to let apps make use of the user's advertising ID, and to let apps run in the background, as well as turning the SmartScreen web filter on." Microsofts' initial communication about the problem seemed to be designed to dismiss the issue, but a later press release admitted the mistake. Darren Allan of TechRadar said "In the future, hopefully Microsoft will come clean on any issues in a swifter manner, and not trot out meaningless statements like the first one the company issued on this matter – frankly, radio silence would have been more palatable than that initial communication."

In late December 2015 Yusuf Mehdi, Microsoft's Corporate Vice President, Windows and Devices Group indicated that Windows 10 had passed the milestone of 200 million computers running the operating system. While attempting to show its popularity he raised more privacy concerns, stating "Windows 10 users have spent over 44.5 billion minutes using the Microsoft Edge browser that debuted with the new operating system, asked 2.5 billion questions using Cortana, viewed 82 billion photos in the Windows 10 Photo app, spent over 4 billion hours playing PC games on Windows 10 and streamed more than 6.6 million hours of Xbox One games to Windows 10 PCs." This is all data that Windows 10 devices reported on their users. Darren Allan of TechRadar noted, "the real issue here is the uncertainty over what data is being recorded, and the fact that the user has no control or real say in the process". Martin Brinkmann of GHacks noted of this, "The statistics indicate that Microsoft may be collecting more data than initially thought. While it is unclear what data is exactly collected, it is clear that the company is collecting information about the use of individual applications and programs on Windows at the very least. The real question is how fine grained the data collecting actually is. For instance, is Windows 10 recording what users do in Edge or the actual questions that individual users ask Cortana?"

There is now a whole industry showing users how to reduce the invasive privacy problems in Windows 10, like this article by Ian Paul of PCWorld.

Canada's federal privacy commissioner is concerned about Windows 10 privacy issues and has launched an investigation into it.

Russian government members are also concerned about Windows 10 passing information to the US government and have proposed banning it for Russian government use. Adarsh Verma writing on Foss Bytes says "Russian lawyers have filed a complaint with the Prosecutor General’s Office, demanding strict actions against the OS and consider the option of Windows 10 ban in Russia. They have claimed that Windows 10 is being used to collect user information and it infringes the local Russian laws."

In July 2016 the French National Data Protection Commission (CNIL) cited Microsoft for multiple issues with Windows 10 and gave the company three months to fix the issues or face large fines. The areas of violation of French law identified included: Irrelevant or excessive data collected, lack of security, lack of individual consent and that data still being transferred outside EU on a “safe harbour” basis, even after that was ruled by courts as illegal.

In February 2017 the European Union data protection watchdogs (Article 29 Working Party) still had concerns about privacy settings in Windows 10 and how data being collected from user's computers was being stored and used. The group said "Microsoft should clearly explain what kinds of personal data are processed for what purposes. Without such information, consent cannot be informed, and therefore, not valid." Microsoft has not responded to inquiries on this subject.

Software-as-a-service

In July 2016 it came to light that Windows 10 will include a US$7 per month subscription fee, starting with enterprise users. It is expected that this fee will eventually be extended to all users, including consumers.

Microsoft indicated from the introduction of Windows 10 that it would be the last version of Windows and would be just continuously updated, rather than replaced by future versions. The company also indicated that it was moving to a "software-as-a-service" model, which usually involves subscription fees for users.

Windows Defender

If you turn this off for any reason, such as a malfunction in it or it gives a false positive, it will turn itself back on.

Browser choices

Windows 10, when installed as an upgrade, will change your browser to Microsoft Edge, even if you had another browser installed, like Firefox or Chrome.

Mozilla chief executive Chris Beard said that Microsoft is using the upgrade process to "throw away the choice your customers have made about the Internet experience they want, and replace it with the Internet experience Microsoft wants them to have."

Forced updates

Making all updates automatic and mandatory has some benefits in that it reduces vulnerabilities in the system that have been identified and patches issued for, but many experts have problems with what goes along with this.

Computer book author Adrian Kingsley-Hughes notes that in the past Microsoft has tried to force unwanted "junkware", as he terms it, on users through updates, including the Bing toolbar and Skype, both of which are owned by Microsoft.

As part of the update process the computer will automatically reboot itself.

Updates are delivered via a sharing process like bit torrent and are all cached on your computer. This means that you not only download the updates, but you are sharing them with other Windows users, as well, which may use up a lot of your monthly bandwidth cap, depending on the size of the updates. This can be disabled, but the default is "on".

Another issue with forced updates is that in the past Microsoft has sent out updates that disable the operating system or cause other problems. This includes updates for Windows 10.

Joel Hruska of Extreme Tech said, "for decades, one of the anchor points in the Apple vs. Microsoft debate was that Microsoft gave you more control over your OS than Apple did, even if it layered that control in obtuse menus and difficult-to-parse options. With Windows 10, the balance of power has clearly shifted. The company that brought us the “Scroogled” campaign now hoovers up your data in ways that would make Google jealous. It selects defaults that allow it to use your bandwidth to distribute its own software without any exposed option for how and when that sharing takes place."

In March 2016 it was identified that Microsoft has included several non-security updates within a single critical security update for Internet Explorer 11 (KB3139929). Most of these bundled updates seem reasonable but hiding them inside a security updated is deceptive. The update to be wary of is "Updated Internet Explorer 11 capabilities to upgrade Windows 8.1 and Windows 7" (KB3146449). As described in the update article: "This update adds functionality to Internet Explorer 11 on some computers that lets users learn about Windows 10 or start an upgrade to Windows 10". Users need to be aware that this may lead to an unintentional upgrade to Windows 10, whether you use IE11 or an alternate browser, as IE is integrated into the operating system.

Hardware Issues

Microsoft has announced that new computers with Intel’s Kaby Lake processor, Qualcomm’s 8996 processor, or AMD’s Bristol Ridge processor will not support earlier versions of Windows and must use Windows 10.

Also the Windows 10 installer often does not find Intel chipset drivers resulting in some motherboard devices not functioning properly or that they may not be detected under Windows without the correct chipset drivers being present.

Furthermore the default Windows 10 driver for Broadcom Ethernet does not work properly at all.

Pricing

Windows 10 was free if you upgraded from Windows 7 SP1 or Windows 8.1 home or professional editions prior to 29 July 2016. If your earlier version was a non-genuine version (ie: pirated) then your version of Windows 10 will also be non-genuine. Enterprise editions are not eligible for the free upgrade.

Solitaire isn't exactly free

The long-packaged solitaire card game that has always come with Windows is still included, but it includes lots of advertising. If you want to get rid of the ads it will cost you US$1.49 per month or US$9.99 per year.

Mark Hachman, Senior Editor at PC World said "it does seem a bit odd that Microsoft can make Windows 10—an entire operating system, mind you—a free upgrade, while asking you to pay to remove ads. If this is the future of Windows as a service, count me out."

Dual booting

If you have a dual boot computer with one partition running Windows and another running a Linux distribution you may lose the ability to boot to the Linux distribution after upgrading to Windows 10 as it seems to disable GRUB, the Linux bootloader.

External dial-up modems

The US Robotics model 5637 has been recommended as a good external modem for Linux, Mac and Windows versions except Windows 10. US Robotics has indicated that there is an issue with Windows 10 that prevents it from working with this modem. As of 10 November 2017, the modem will work with Windows 10, but there may be some initial problems.

Driver issues

To run some applications, like the Audacity free software audio editor Windows 10 may require new audio drivers, since with upgrades to Windows 10 from earlier versions of Windows not all hardware may be properly supported.

Broken internet connection

In early December 2016 Microsoft issued an update to Windows 10 that in some cases has broken its connection to the DSL modem and hence to the internet. Windows 10 seems to assign the computer a DHCP address of 169.254.157.29 instead of a modem-assigned network DHCP address, such as 192.168.1.101.

This can be confirmed by using another device or operating system on the same device to connect to the modem. If an internet connection still works then Windows 10 settings are most likely the issue.

To fix this go to "Network Settings" in the Windows 10 computer and see if the IP address is marked as "DHCP" or "Fixed" and switch them from the one to the other. Changing to static IP will automatically toggle the DNS check box and you will then have to return both manually to the automatic setting.

This Microsoft help article How to reset TCP/IP by using the NetShell utility may be of use in solving this issue as well.

Preventing a Windows 10 Upgrade to Windows 7 & 8

If you are running Windows 7 or 8 Microsoft will try to upgrade it to Windows 10. You can prevent this using the GWX Control Panel tool from Ultimate Outsider or Never Ten from Gibson Research Associates.

Another method is editing the registry values to prevent upgrades and the "nag" notices.

See also Microsoft Strikes Again – How to NOT Upgrade to Windows 10

By May 2016 Microsoft had made it easier to refuse an upgrade to Windows 10, providing a dialogue box option that says, "Click here to change the upgrade schedule or cancel the scheduled update." Then in late May 2016 they changed how the upgrade screen worked in a seeming bid to fool users into upgrading. Make Use of writer Dave Parrack described it, "Microsoft is getting increasingly desperate in its bid to persuade us all to upgrade to Windows 10. And its latest effort employs dirty tactics, essentially fooling people into upgrading to Windows 10 by changing how the nagscreen works. Up to now, users who don’t want to upgrade to Windows 10 could just keep Microsoft happy by closing the nagscreen whenever it popped up. But that’s no longer the case. Now, closing the nagscreen means you’re giving Microsoft permission to upgrade your computer to Windows 10."

If you do get tricked into installing Windows 10 it can be easily reverted if done within a month.

Preventing Windows 10-style Tracking in Windows 7 & 8

Microsoft also tries to add the user tracking from Windows 10 to users of Windows 7 and 8. This can be fixed as explained at Stop Windows Telemetry/Tracking/Upgrading to Win10. That article advises "The advice from many experts now is to not go near Windows 10. Do not install it. Retain your privacy and control over your systems."

Installing Windows 10 with a Windows 7 or 8 product key

​​​​​For the time being, you can still install Windows 10 if you have a valid copy of Windows 7 or 8 You have to download the Microsoft installer for the same version (Home or Professional) as the version of Windows you already have.

If you don't know your product key, you can get it form your current version (7 or 8) of Windows by using the Magical Jelly Bean Product Key Finder.

You download download the installer, in USB or DVD format, put it on a USB or DVD, boot from it, and give the product key when requested.

Alternatives

Free Linux DVDs in the rack at the NCF office.

If you have reviewed the information on Windows 10 and decided that you do not want to use it, then there are many alternatives available.

If you are already running Windows 7 or 8 and wish to keep using it then just avoid upgrading or having the Windows 10 privacy-violating software installed in your Windows 7 or 8 software, as described above.

If you have hardware already running Windows 10 then you can replace the software with another operating system instead. There are hundreds of Linux distributions available for free that will run on Windows 10 hardware and that provide good privacy, stability and functionality. The NCF office has stocks of free Linux DVDs for installation.

Available at the office are DVDs for:

External links

General

Reviews and tips

Free Software

Dial-up

Alternatives